The Invading Sea
  • News
  • Commentary
  • Multimedia
  • Public opinion
  • About
No Result
View All Result
The Invading Sea
  • News
  • Commentary
  • Multimedia
  • Public opinion
  • About
No Result
View All Result
The Invading Sea
No Result
View All Result

The real cost of living in paradise: Florida’s insurance crisis needs root-cause solutions

Suppressing premiums with subsidies or caps gives consumers false security, encouraging building in unsafe zones

by Don Brown
February 24, 2025
in Commentary
0

By Don Brown, former Florida state representative

When the next $50 billion hurricane strikes Florida, the question is: Who’s going to pay for it? While many Floridians expect insurers to cover the damage, the reality is a bit more complicated.

Insurers can falter, premiums may fall short and, ultimately, the financial burden shifts to homeowners and taxpayers. Florida’s insurance crisis exposes the unsustainable expectation that we can build in high-risk areas and count on others to pick up the tab when disaster strikes.

Flooded houses from Hurricane Debby in the Laurel Meadows community of Sarasota (iStock image)
Flooded houses from Hurricane Debby in the Laurel Meadows community of Sarasota (iStock image)

Florida’s unique climate and growth patterns make it especially vulnerable to hurricanes, flooding and storm surges. This has driven up insurance costs, but high premiums are simply a reflection of real risk. Suppressing these premiums with subsidies or caps gives consumers false security, encouraging building in unsafe zones. This cycle burdens our insurance system, exposes more people to financial loss and promotes a fragile market.

In any open market, price signals risk – and when these signals are distorted, it’s like taking away a warning light. Proper pricing not only discourages risky development but also promotes safe and sustainable practices by directing homeowners to safer, less vulnerable locations.

Government intervention often aims to make insurance more accessible, but in practice, it exacerbates risk. Artificially low premiums lure people to high-risk areas, insulate them from real costs and create what’s known as moral hazard – the tendency to take on more risk because someone else is sharing the burden. When government programs make it cheaper to live in flood zones, they unintentionally encourage risky building and erode incentives for mitigation measures like storm-resistant construction.

Programs like the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) illustrate this well. Since 1968, the NFIP has provided subsidized flood insurance to make premiums more affordable in high-risk areas. But with rates that don’t reflect actual risk, a small percentage of properties repeatedly make claims after flooding, driving NFIP into billions of dollars of debt. By lowering costs, the NFIP fosters a cycle of rebuilding in flood zones, risking taxpayer funds without reducing exposure.

Don Brown
Don Brown

Florida’s Citizens Property Insurance Corp. offers a similar example. Established to provide last-resort coverage, Citizens attracted policyholders with low premiums, encouraging development in hurricane-prone areas. Now, with billions in potential liabilities, the state could face a taxpayer crisis if a major hurricane hits.

While subsidies and price caps tackle only the surface, resilient communities like Babcock Ranch are excellent case studies that show that strategic planning is possible. Built with advanced stormwater systems, solar power and underground utilities, Babcock Ranch sits 25-30 feet above sea level, sidestepping flood risks and preserving power even in storms. This approach balances development with long-term risk management, offering a path forward that doesn’t rely on subsidies but on smart design and real resilience.

Floridians must recognize that living in paradise comes with inherent risks. Real progress requires shifting focus from short-term premium reductions to addressing the root causes of rising costs. By allowing insurance prices to reflect actual risk, encouraging safer building practices and limiting subsidies to cases of true need, we can build a sustainable market – and state – that’s resilient, realistic and better prepared for the challenges ahead.

Don Brown is a former state representative and former chair of the House Insurance Regulation Subcommittee. Banner image: Some of the destruction to homes caused by Hurricane Ian in Florida (iStock image).

Sign up for The Invading Sea newsletter by visiting here. To support The Invading Sea, click here to make a donation. If you are interested in submitting an opinion piece to The Invading Sea, email Editor Nathan Crabbe at ncrabbe@fau.edu. To learn more about flood zones, watch the video below.

Tags: Babcock RanchCitizens Property Insuranceclimate resilienceflood zonesNational Flood Insurance Programproperty insurance
Previous Post

Puerto Rico must not be left in the dark

Next Post

‘A fertilizer for the sea’

Next Post
Aboard the RV Neil Armstrong, University of Miami graduate student Hope Elliott, left, prepares vials of seawater into which Saharan dust particles and volcanic ash were injected.. (Image courtesy of Hope Elliott/University of Miami)

‘A fertilizer for the sea’

Twitter Facebook Instagram Youtube

About this website

The Invading Sea is a nonpartisan source for news, commentary and educational content about climate change and other environmental issues affecting Florida. The site is managed by Florida Atlantic University’s Center for Environmental Studies in the Charles E. Schmidt College of Science.

 

 

Sign up for The Invading Sea newsletter

Sign up to receive the latest climate change news and commentary in your email inbox by visiting here.

Donate to The Invading Sea

We are seeking continuing support for the website and its staff. Click here to learn more and donate.

Calendar of past posts

February 2025
S M T W T F S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
232425262728  
« Jan   Mar »

© 2022 The Invading Sea

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Commentary
  • Multimedia
  • Public opinion
  • About

© 2022 The Invading Sea

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In