As beachside communities begin rebuilding in the wake of two recent catastrophic hurricanes, they should ask whether beach nourishment offers enough protection from erosion and flooding.
Hurricane Michael struck Florida’s Panhandle as a category 4 storm with 155mph winds. Barely a month earlier, Hurricane Florence flooded the Carolinas when the category 1 storm slowly washed over that region. In both cases, the hurricanes changed coastlines as beaches and dunes were overrun by waves, or in some cases, completely eroded.
Typically, recovery plans call for large-scale beach nourishment and dune construction to protect areas behind the beach from future erosion and flooding. A study by FIU coastal geologist Randall Parkinson suggests this practice will become even costlier and more controversial as the availability of sand dwindles.
“Sand is not a renewable resource,” Parkinson said. “When sand is eroded from the beach during a storm, it typically accumulates in offshore areas as a very thin layer that can’t be dredge again to construct a new beach or dune.”
An increase in the rate of sea-level rise and the threat of more powerful, slow-moving hurricanes will drive up the demand for sand. With companies already spending more to harvest sand in deeper waters farther off shore, the cost of sand could rise even higher.
In Florida’s Panhandle alone, Parkinson’s study found that nourishment costs rose from about $5 million annually in the 1990s to more than $10 million in the 2000s. Depending on sea-level rise, the cost to nourish Panhandle beaches for the next 84 years could one day exceed $72 million per year.
To make matters worse, data from the Panhandle shows offshore sand deposits might be darker than the fine grains of lighter colored sand favored by residents and tourists.
As coastal communities in Florida and around the world rebuild after disasters, they will be faced with difficult decisions about coastal construction projects, Parkinson said.
“I think these recent events remind us all that the coastal zone is a really high-risk area that is going to become even more vulnerable flooding and erosion as the climate changes,” Parkinson said. “We need to be thinking of Plan B before the next big one arrives.”
“The Invading Sea” is a collaboration of four South Florida media organizations — the South Florida Sun Sentinel, Miami Herald, Palm Beach Post and WLRN Public Media.