The Invading Sea
  • About
  • Editorials
    • Earlier opinion pieces in South Florida media about climate, rising seas
  • In the News
  • Resources
    • What You Can Do
    • Frequently Asked Questions
No Result
View All Result
The Invading Sea
  • About
  • Editorials
    • Earlier opinion pieces in South Florida media about climate, rising seas
  • In the News
  • Resources
    • What You Can Do
    • Frequently Asked Questions
No Result
View All Result
The Invading Sea
No Result
View All Result

Leaders need to negotiate a deal that provides enough water for Atlanta’s residents, Georgia’s farmers and Florida’s oyster industry

by Contributors
December 17, 2019
in Editorials
0

A hearing officer has dealt Florida the nearest thing to a fatal blow in its long-running water war with Georgia. In a report last week, the special master, Senior U.S. Circuit Court Judge Paul J. Kelly Jr., found that Florida’s mismanagement – not Georgia’s use of water upstream – is more to blame for the collapse of Florida’s oyster industry in Apalachicola Bay.

However sweeping the report, this case calls for a political accommodation and a smarter strategy for consuming shared state waters.

Florida has long complained that Georgia uses too much water from the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin. The Chattahoochee flows south from Georgia to join Alabama’s Flint River and become the Apalachicola River from the Florida state line to Apalachicola Bay.

The Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River Basin

The bay used to produce 90 percent of all of Florida’s oysters and 10 percent of all the oysters consumed in the U.S. But these days, the industry has dwindled to almost nothing.

The balance of fresh and salt water in Apalachicola Bay is crucial to the growth and development of the oysters there. But the loss of fresh water flow during a 2013 drought turned the bay salty and so damaged the oyster beds that the area was declared a federal disaster. Florida maintains that Georgia farmers and Atlanta-area residents use too much water, decreasing downstream flows and devastating Apalachicola Bay.

But the special master appointed by the U.S. Supreme Court to hear the case disagreed last week. In an 81-page report, Kelly found that Florida failed to make its case. He instead blamed Florida for allowing oysters to be over-harvested and for failing to re-shell the oyster beds. “Florida has not shown by clear and convincing evidence,” he declared flatly, “that the oyster collapse was caused by Georgia rather than another cause (like mismanagement of the resource or drought), and Florida has not shown any other harms to the Bay.”

The ruling is a serious setback following a split Supreme Court decision last year that gave Florida another chance to argue its case. Kelly’s report, made in the form of a recommendation to the court, is a clear victory for Georgia and another hurdle in fairly distributing the basin’s water.

Kelly also said he would not recommend that the court grant Florida’s request for a decree apportioning the waters, finding that Georgia’s water use was “reasonable” and questioning whether the benefits of restricting water use would outweigh the costs.

It should not be the special master’s role to weigh the potential benefits of fairly regulating water use. The court would benefit from further scrutiny in this case.

The special master acknowledged that “low flows played some role in the oyster population decline,” and he further pointed to drought as a significant factor, finding that Georgia “has not effectively curbed” water use by its agricultural sector during dry periods. A fuller appreciation of conservation measures that could come into play might help in resolving this dispute.

The states need a solution that’s fair, enforceable and durable, and which provides for the most efficient use of these natural resources. This latest report from the special master still doesn’t provide a fair basis for ending the case.

“The Invading Sea” is the opinion arm of the Florida Climate Reporting Network, a collaborative of news organizations across the state focusing on the threats posed by the warming climate.

Tags: Apalachicola BayFloridaGeorgiaoystersSenior U.S. Circuit Court Judge Paul J. Kelly Jr.the Apalachicola-Chattahoochee-Flint River BasinThe Tampa Bay Times Editorial Board
Previous Post

Pollution is killing Biscayne Bay, there’s very little time to save it, and it’s going to cost a lot of money to rescue it

Next Post

South Florida's Fast-Changing Landscape Makes It Harder For Audubon To Count Birds

Related Posts

Covid-19, hurricane season and plastics – oh my!
Influencers

Recycling is not the solution to the plastic pollution crisis

by Catherine Uden
February 23, 2021
Anna Sampson: Individuals, businesses first need to calculate their carbon footprint before they can reduce it
The Business of Climate Change

Anna Sampson: Individuals, businesses first need to calculate their carbon footprint before they can reduce it

by Kevin Mims
February 22, 2021
Solar storage can be a lifesaver, particularly during hurricane season
Influencers

Lawmakers should allow Florida’s schools to install solar panels that will save them money and educate students

by Michele Drucker
February 13, 2021
Next Post
South Florida’s Fast-Changing Landscape Makes It Harder For Audubon To Count Birds

South Florida's Fast-Changing Landscape Makes It Harder For Audubon To Count Birds

Twitter Facebook

About the Project

The Invading Sea is a collaboration by news organizations across Florida to address the threat we face from sea-level rise. We want to raise awareness, amplify the voice of our region and create a call to action that can’t be ignored. Read More

Archives

Categories

Audio Editorials Faces of Sea Level Rise Influencers In The News Other The Business of Climate Change Video

Watch How the Water Will Rise

sea level rise map
See what happens to your neighborhood as the sea level rises with this interactive map from Climate Central.

© 2021 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Editorials
    • Earlier opinion pieces in South Florida media about climate, rising seas
  • In the News
  • Resources
    • What You Can Do
    • Frequently Asked Questions

© 2021 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In