The Invading Sea
  • About
  • Editorials
    • Earlier opinion pieces in South Florida media about climate, rising seas
  • In the News
  • Resources
    • What You Can Do
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Influencers
No Result
View All Result
The Invading Sea
  • About
  • Editorials
    • Earlier opinion pieces in South Florida media about climate, rising seas
  • In the News
  • Resources
    • What You Can Do
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Influencers
No Result
View All Result
The Invading Sea
No Result
View All Result

A Miami houseboat adapts to climate change. The owners might need to adapt, too — to taxes

With sea levels rising, so do questions of what constitutes housing and how to tax it.

by The Miami Herald Editorial Board
March 31, 2022
in Editorials
0

By the Miami Herald Editorial Board

The houseboat anchored off Miami Beach’s Star Island could easily fit into one of Miami’s upscale neighborhoods. It’s a two-story, white rectangle valued at $5.1 million, with vast expanses of glass, a luxury kitchen, two bedrooms upstairs, space for a gym and a patio with, no doubt, a pretty amazing water view. 

But the Arkup #1, as it is called, doesn’t just look like a mansion. It’s also now being taxed like a mansion. And that’s where an interesting issue has arisen. 

The Miami-Dade County Property Appraiser’s Office has classified the opulent houseboat as a “floating structure,” the Miami Herald reported, not a boat. The office sent a property tax bill of almost $120,000 to the company that owns it and another to the builders, Arkup, for back taxes. Legal challenges are flying, predictably. That’s not necessarily a bad thing.

The Arkup model was originally pitched as an innovative form of housing that will continue to be functional amid rising seas and worsening hurricanes. Inspired by Dutch floating communities, it has adjustable pilings that stabilize it on the sea floor or lift it above the water, like a house on stilts, and is designed as a climate-change housing solution. The Arkup that currently sits in Biscayne Bay is owned by MacKnight International Inc., one of British-born businessman Jonathan Brown’s companies.

If Miami’s future is about resiliency — and there is no doubt it is — we’ll need to iron out new definitions of what constitutes housing and how to tax it. The Arkup is turning into Exhibit A. 

Lawyers for MacKnight International say the Arkup is being unfairly singled out because it doesn’t look like a traditional yacht. They point out that it’s registered with the U.S Coast Guard and can motor along at 5 knots per hour. 

A yacht wouldn’t be subject to property tax. And, the Herald noted, this is the only “floating structure” being taxed by the appraiser’s office. 

“We believe the sole reason our client is in this position — an unconstitutional tax assessment — is because of the shape and the style and the look of this boat,” attorney Ivan Abrams told the Herald. 

But the property appraiser’s office, which sent out the tax bills last fall, says the Arkup “was not built to be primarily used as a means of transportation over water.” It looks like a courtroom is the only place to settle this.

We understand that even wealthy businessmen don’t want to pay taxes they didn’t expect. We also understand that this case could spawn others if taxation of live-aboard housing — from mega yachts to sailboats — becomes a consideration in a climate-changed South Florida. This controversy has resonated in part because it touches on two of the key challenges facing our community: affordability and climate change. 

We’d like to remind the owners that the whole point of the Arkup is to adapt to change. In South Florida, that can mean constructing elevated roadways. Building houses on higher ground. Installing pumps to keep sunny-day floods at bay. Or perhaps — if you’re very, very lucky — it means paying property taxes on a houseboat so luxurious most regular people could never come close to affording it.

This editorial comes from The Miami Herald, which is part of the Invading Sea collaborative of Florida editorial boards focused on the threats posed by the warming climate.

Photo courtesy of the Miami Herald.

Tags: Arkup #1climate changeMacKnight International Inc.Miami houseboatMiami-Dade County Property Appraiser’s Office
Previous Post

SEC should force companies to reveal climate change risks

Next Post

Gov. DeSantis, veto anti-solar bill to save energy independence

Related Posts

Good and bad climate news from the Florida Legislature
Influencers

Good and bad climate news from the Florida Legislature

by Rosemary O'Hara
April 5, 2022
Suffering climate anxiety? You’re not alone.
Influencers

Suffering climate anxiety? You’re not alone.

by Sam Daley-Harris
February 11, 2022
Florida’s climate deniers are using a new buzzword — resiliency
Influencers

Sen. Marco Rubio’s “hotel towel” strategy for climate change

by Pamela McVety
January 27, 2022
Next Post
FPL wants to raise prices again, this time on freedom-loving solar customers

Gov. DeSantis, veto anti-solar bill to save energy independence

Twitter Facebook

About the Project

The Invading Sea is a collaboration by news organizations across Florida to address the threat we face from sea-level rise. We want to raise awareness, amplify the voice of our region and create a call to action that can’t be ignored. Read More

Archives

Categories

Audio Editorials Faces of Sea Level Rise Influencers In The News Other The Business of Climate Change Video

Watch How the Water Will Rise

sea level rise map
See what happens to your neighborhood as the sea level rises with this interactive map from Climate Central.

© 2022 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Editorials
    • Earlier opinion pieces in South Florida media about climate, rising seas
  • In the News
  • Resources
    • What You Can Do
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Influencers

© 2022 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In